Scroll Saw vs Jigsaw for Beginners: Which Tool Should You Buy First?

Scroll Saw vs Jigsaw for Beginners: Which Tool Should You Buy First?

As an Amazon Associate, Beginner Woodshop Tools earns from qualifying purchases.

Choosing your first power saw as a beginner woodworker can feel overwhelming. Two of the most common tools people consider are the scroll saw and the jigsaw. While both can cut curves and shapes, they are designed for very different types of work.

This guide breaks down the differences in plain language so you can confidently choose the right tool for your projects — and avoid wasting money on the wrong one.

---

Quick Comparison: Scroll Saw vs Jigsaw

Feature	Scroll Saw	Jigsaw
Type	Stationary benchtop tool	Handheld portable tool
Best For	Intricate, detailed cuts	General woodworking
Precision	High	Medium
Versatility	Low	High
Ease for Beginners	Moderate	Easy
Typical Projects	Crafts, signs, puzzles	Furniture, boards, curves

Quick takeaway:
Most beginners will get more use from a jigsaw, while a scroll saw is better for detailed craft-focused work.

---

What Is a Scroll Saw?

A scroll saw is a stationary tool that uses a very thin blade mounted vertically. The material is moved slowly by hand, allowing for tight curves and detailed cuts that other saws struggle to make.

Scroll Saw Pros

• Excellent control for intricate designs
• Perfect for crafts and decorative projects
• Can make interior cutouts without edge entry

Scroll Saw Cons

• Limited to thinner materials
• Not useful for straight cuts or large boards
• Takes up permanent bench space

Scroll Saws Are Best For:

• Craft woodworkers
• Decorative signs and ornaments
• Puzzles and fretwork
• Detailed artistic projects

---

Best Beginner Scroll Saws (Good Starting Options)

When choosing a beginner scroll saw, look for:

• Variable speed
• Easy blade changes
• Solid vibration control

Recommended beginner-friendly scroll saw types:

• 16-inch variable speed scroll saws (best balance of size and control)
• Entry-level benchtop models with tool-free blade changes

WEN 16″ Variable Speed Scroll Saw – A popular beginner scroll saw offering good control, easy blade changes, and solid value for craft projects.https://amzn.to/4be9Klm

---

What Is a Jigsaw?

A jigsaw is a handheld saw with a vertical blade that moves up and down. It’s one of the most versatile tools a beginner can own and is often the first power saw people buy.

Jigsaw Pros

• Extremely versatile
• Cuts straight lines and curves
• Works on thicker wood
• Easy to store and transport

Jigsaw Cons

• Less precise for tight curves
• Requires practice for clean cuts
• Can wander on thin materials

Jigsaws Are Best For:

• General woodworking
• Cutting boards and panels
• Curves in furniture projects
• DIY home projects

---

Best Beginner Jigsaws (Good Starting Options)

For beginners, a good jigsaw should have:

• Variable speed control
• Orbital settings
• Comfortable grip
• Easy blade changes

Recommended beginner-friendly jigsaw types:

• Corded jigsaws for steady power
• Entry-level cordless jigsaws for portability

DEWALT Corded Jigsaw – A reliable, beginner-friendly jigsaw with variable speed and excellent control for general woodworking projects.https://amzn.to/4slGYp9

DEWALT Cordless Jigsaw – A reliable, beginner-friendly jigsaw with variable speed and excellent control for general woodworking projects.https://amzn.to/4bgSbkF

---

Scroll Saw vs Jigsaw: Which Is Better for Beginners?

Choose a Jigsaw First If:

• You want one tool that can do many jobs
• You’re building furniture or general projects
• You’re new to power tools and want flexibility

Choose a Scroll Saw First If:

• You focus on crafts and artistic projects
• You need very fine, detailed cuts
• You enjoy slow, precise woodworking

Honest Recommendation

For most beginners, a jigsaw is the better first purchase. It offers more versatility, handles a wider range of projects, and remains useful even as your skills grow. If you’re ready to get started, a well-reviewed beginner jigsaw like the DEWALT Cordless Jigsaw is a solid choice. As a beginner I choose a cordless Dewalt for versatility and reliability. If you’ve decided that a jigsaw is the right first tool, see our complete guide to choosing the best beginner jigsaw

A scroll saw becomes valuable once you know you want to focus on detailed craft work.

---

Free Download: Beginner Tool Comparison PDF

Download our beginner-friendly comparison guide to quickly review the differences between these two tools.

---

👉 Download: Scroll Saw vs Jigsaw for Beginners

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a jigsaw replace a scroll saw?

Not completely. A jigsaw can cut curves, but it cannot match the precision of a scroll saw for tight, detailed work.

Is a scroll saw safe for beginners?

Yes, scroll saws are generally beginner-safe when used properly, but they are more specialized than jigsaws.

Which tool should I buy first?

If you’re unsure, start with a jigsaw. You can always add a scroll saw later if your projects require more detail.

---

Final Thoughts

Choosing between a scroll saw and a jigsaw comes down to what you want to build. If versatility and general woodworking are your goals, a jigsaw is the smarter first tool. If intricate craft projects are your passion, a scroll saw may be worth the investment sooner.

Starting with the right tool makes woodworking more enjoyable, safer, and far less frustrating.